Guest Editorial Series by Ernest A. Canning
This is the second of our three-part series advancing the hypothesis that one must turn to economics to make sense of the so-called ‘War on Drugs’ and the U.S. government’s seemingly irrational obsession with shutting down something as innocuous as medicinal marijuana dispensaries.
PART 1 examined both historical and recent links between the CIA and the illicit drug trade. It explored the extent to which the so-called ‘War on Drugs’ has been used as cover for the CIA’s covert import of narcotics, both into the U.S. and other nations, in order to fund the mischief the Agency engages in on behalf of U.S. Empire. It postulated that the government’s opposition to controlled legalization, taxation and medical, educational and psychological assistance in avoiding substance abuse is the product of an illicit supplier shutting down the competition.
Here, we will examine the profitability of the Prison Industrial Complex in the U.S. and the extent to which the world’s largest prison population provides a ready source of slave labor for some of the world’s largest corporations…
Domestic costs of ‘War on Drugs’
In “America’s War on Drugs: Misguided efforts that waste resources and sacrifice civil liberties” Mike Kroll attributes President Richard Nixon’s declaration of a ‘war on drugs’ to the growing counterculture movement in the 1960s spawned by opposition to the war in Vietnam. This was followed by the Controlled Substance Act of 1970, which, as Kroll describes, “greatly increased Federal funding of law enforcement against drugs. Both the effort and funding [were] ratcheted up again during the Reagan administration.”
Kroll reports:
Although the correlation between the 1970 passage of the Controlled Substances Act and the exponential growth in the U.S. prison population is depicted in the graph at right, the surprising feature, as reflected in a discussion at Alternet about a study by researcher Jon Gettman, Ph.D., is the estimated $43 billion annual cost in controlling the least dangerous of the “controlled substances” — marijuana. The $43 billion is broken down, according to the study, as “$10.7 billion in direct law enforcement costs, and $31.1 billion in lost tax revenues.” And that may be an underestimate, at least on the law enforcement side, since Gettman made his calculations prior to the FBI’s release of its statistics for 2009.
Although law enforcement effectuated 858,408 arrests on marijuana charges in 2009 — or one American every 37 seconds — marijuana use increased by 8% over the previous year.
Gettman estimates that illicit marijuana sales generate $112 billion annually, which helps to explain why Mexican drug cartels have engaged in a deadly war both amongst one another and with the Mexican government. 28,000 lives have been lost in those wars since 2006 and have led to a proposal by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to spend an even greater proportion of our already depleted National Treasury to escalate the ‘War on Drugs’ in Mexico, as patterned on our multi-billion dollar military aid program in Columbia. President Obama echoed that approach at the April 14, 2012 Summit of the Americas when, as reported by Amy Goodman, he “ruled out legalization” and pledged, instead, to spend “more than $130 million in aid for increasing security and pursuing narco-traffickers.”
What Clinton and Obama failed to mention is that our aid to Columbia, ostensibly to counter narcotics and terrorism, has funded Columbian death squads, who, according to Phillip Alston, the UN Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial Executions, often murder innocents “for soldiers’ personal benefit or profit.”
Prison Industrial Complex as an alternative to outsourcing
The statistics are compelling.
As observed by Vicky Pelaez of Global Research:
As revealed by the film, American Drug War: The Last White Hope (see video clip below), as well as Pelaez’ account, the size of the U.S. prison population, which is disproportionately comprised of African-Americans and Hispanics, is the product of two perverse economic incentives — (1) a privatized prison industry whose financial success is dependent upon greater numbers of prisoners serving lengthier sentences, and (2) the availability of a slave labor pool to corporate America.
Pelaez reports:
Pelaez adds that between 1980 and 1994 profits from prison labor soared “from $392 million to $1.31 billion” and that, while some inmates receive minimum wage, “in privately-run prisons, they receive as little as 17 cents per hour.”
Pelaez’s article, in quoting Kevin Mannix, the former chairman of the Oregon GOP, underscores how this form of slave labor has furnished an attractive alternative to outsourcing. “Mannix,” Pelaez reported, “recently urged Nike to cut its production in Indonesia and bring it to his state, telling the shoe manufacturer, ‘there won’t be any transportation costs; we’re offering you competitive prison labor [here].'” — Something to bear in mind the next time you hear a Republican crowing about “jobs creation.”
While the number of state inmates, more than 2 million, far exceeds the 125,000 federal inmates, 97% of whom are sentenced for non-violent crimes, the supply of those federal inmates is assured by lengthy mandatory sentences for narcotics possession, according to Pelaez. Some, like actor/comedian Tommy Chong, served time not for either the possession or sale of narcotics but because he was entrapped by former Attorney General John Ashcroft’s “Operation Pipe Dreams” when Chong’s son shipped a glass pipe to a county that prohibits them. (See video below).
The same U.S. government whose CIA has been responsible for turning Afghanistan into the world’s leading supplier of heroin and marijuana, spent $12 million to go after glass pipes (bongs).
In supporting an accusation leveled by a Progressive Labor Party study that the U.S. has imitated “Nazi Germany with respect to forced slave labor,” Pelaez writes:
Sounds like the Prison Industrial Complex services the Military Industrial Complex. Synergy!
In short, legalization poses a direct threat corporate America’s bottom line. End the ‘War on Drugs’ and you deplete the available pool of prison slave labor, as well as the profitability of private prisons.
PART 1 of this series ended by asking if the efforts of the DOJ and DEA to shut down medical marijuana cultivation in California reflect an effort by “an illicit supplier [to shut] down the competition?”
In PART 3 of this series, our final report, we’ll address our government’s continuing resistance to domestic and foreign efforts to break free of the phony ‘War on Drugs’ and the organized crime wave that drug prohibition has fostered. | UPDATE: PART 3 is now here…
A video clip from the film American Drug War: The Last White Hope follows…
Ernest A. Canning has been an active member of the California state bar since 1977. Mr. Canning has received both undergraduate and graduate degrees in political science as well as a juris doctor. He is also a Vietnam vet (4th Infantry, Central Highlands 1968). Follow him on Twitter: @Cann4ing.
always skeptical about war on drugs, always felt it was a new form of slavery, but had no idea how much defense contractors were using this.
So taxpayers pay to lock up non-violent drug users, then rich corporations use this enslaved cheap labor (we have already paid to keep them fed, housed, and locked up) to make even more money. This is what a private prison system and private profit from prisoners breeds.
Meanwhile, we target black and latino communities with war on drugs (mostly just a war on black people) while also due to discrimination, horrible schools etc, one of their few potential employers that does not discriminate as much is the military…so black folk lucky enough not to be arrested get to fight wars in armor made by other black folks locked up for doing drugs at a rate 10-20 times that of white people doing same thing. And regular white and black folks get to pay for wars and prisons while corporations make huge profits off of what the taxpayers have almost solely subsidized.
And all the misery caused to families by parents being locked up, by parents being in combat, by parents being away…such a inhumane and wasteful system, all so some people can make $20 million instead of $10 million
Ernest Canning…you are a fantastic journalist!
Mr. Canning,
It’s a shame that the term “conspiracy theory” has been corrupted to mean “crazy, wildly improbable, paranoid.”
Sadly, there is nothing crazy, wildly improbable or paranoid about the facts you’ve presented and yet they prove the theory that our government has for years conspired to use its drug laws for nefarious purposes.
I hope it’s not too “tinfoil hat” of me to ask if you think Obama’s campaign promises re: easing up on medical cannabis might have been a set-up for his later turning the DOJ loose i.e. to lull the cannabis industry and its consumers into expansion and complacency so there’d be even more easy arrests ?
Also, while I applaud your courage and thoroughness, any solutions to this madness which you might provide would be worthy of a standing ovation.
Thanks much for your hard work. If America wasn’t such an idealogical battlefield, you’d be universally hailed as among its great patriots.
Donna Bogart de Joynt @3 asked:
As I see it, Donna, the ‘War on Drugs,’ like the so-called ‘free trade’ agreements that opened the door of outsourcing the U.S. manufacturing base in search of $2/day slave wages in Asia, has been pretty much a bi-partisan affair.
While I’ve identified, by name, Obama, Clinton, Nixon, Holder & Ashcroft, the true source is structural. It is the product of what John Perkins in Confessions of an Economic Hit Man describes as the “corporatocracy.” It is part of the systemic injustice that accompanies a system that places the wealth and power of the greedy few above the needs of the many.
Hasn’t all this been public for the last 20+ years? 1992? First Gulf War? Remember?
This is chickenshit coverage.
NAME THE BANKS ERNEST!
I guess the demands that outsourced labor be returned the US is being answered by the for profit prison industry – what fine citizens they are. With a bonus of giving inmates working skills – I marvel at their hunanitarian efforts.
Not sure, Off the Grid, what you mean by “all this.” Since some of the events I refer to occurred over the past week, the answer is “no”, not “all” has been public for the past 20 years — certainly the chart I posted in Part I about the increase in Afghan opium production subsequent to the late 2001 U.S. invasion was not available in 1992 — or is it your opinion that if the U.S./CIA engaged in activities 20 years ago, there is no need to explore whether these activities have transpired since.
As to banks, if you have any in mind that you feel are worthy of mention — in addition to BCCI, which is discussed in Part 1 — feel free to add a comment, with appropriate links, setting for why you feel they should have been mentioned.
While you’re at it, perhaps you could be a little less obtuse in explaining why you feel my series amounts to “chickenshit coverage.”
Frankly, it is “chickenshit” for someone who posts under a pseudonym to level such a charge in comments without backing it up, which you certainly did not do by linking to an unlabeled, one hour forty minute video that neither I, nor I suspect anyone else, intends to wade through in order to ascertain what in the Hell you are trying to say.
If you’ve personally written something that you feel does a better job on this issue, I’m sure our readers would be delighted if you shared it with an appropriate link.
I’m eager to hear what you’ll say on the foreign problems. I’ve read that a few Latin American countries are considering legalization, but I don’t think it will do much if the US doesn’t follow suit. We’re the world’s biggest drug market, and something like 90% of the narcotics and pot in this country come from Mexico. In turn, the stuff that comes through Mexico is trafficked through Central and South America. America’s a world leader in ways a lot of people don’t even realize, and I don’t think foreign ountries will be able to solve their own drug problems until we enact some sensible policies.
I can’t believe that more people don’t understand how much the Drug War really costs us taxpayers. Even if we’re not going to decriminalize, a far more viable solution to the problem of addiction would be to “sentence” people to drug rehab. Study after study has shown that people who go to rehab instead of prison are FAR less likely to become recidivists. Still, ignorant people clamor for punishment for people who need help. I’m not too hopeful we’ll see any big changes any time soon.